Decision Mastery Check the Evidence

Survivorship Filter

Say this

I'm seeing the survivors — where are the ones who didn't make it?

Do this now 2 min

Before drawing conclusions from a success story, write: Who tried the same approach and failed? Would I know about them if they existed? If the answer is no, your evidence is incomplete — you're only seeing the winners.

Use when

You're making a decision based on examples of what worked — successful companies, people, strategies.

Avoid when

You have access to comprehensive data that includes both successes and failures.


Why it works

Success stories are visible. Failure is silent. Basing decisions on visible successes alone is like studying only the planes that came back and concluding that where they were hit doesn't matter.

For every startup success story you’ve read, there are hundreds of identical attempts you’ve never heard of. They had the same idea, similar timing, comparable talent — they just didn’t make it. But nobody writes articles about them, so your mental database is entirely composed of survivors. This is the most dangerous data set to reason from, because it systematically excludes the evidence that would change your conclusion. The classic example: studying successful entrepreneurs to find common traits and concluding that risk-taking and persistence are the keys. But the failed entrepreneurs were also risk-taking and persistent. The difference was often luck, timing, or circumstances — none of which show up in survivor interviews.


Go deeper · 8 min read
Survivorship Bias: Why Success Stories Are the Worst Source of Strategy
Spotting that you're only seeing the winners is step one. The trap underneath it is that the riskiest moves look most reliable for the same reason, and this is how you put a number on the failures nobody recorded.
Related tools
The newsletter

One tool a week

How you think, decide, lead, focus, and stay steady under pressure. A specific way to practice one move before the next seven days are out. Grounded in evidence, not self-help.

One email a week. Leave whenever. Powered by Buttondown.